I am an unabashed dork. This fact cannot be denied by any who know me- indeed, many would rush to back up this assertion, their heads frantically nodding. One particular aspect of this is my fascination with languages, dead and living, old and new. I am a Tolkein fanboy, and have always wanted to peer into the constructed languages of Middle Earth. Somewhat more embarrassing is my love of Star Trek, although I have no intention of learning any Klingon. Personally I find the more interesting of Star Trek’s cultures to be the Romulans, closely followed by the Vulcans.

I recently learned that there are folks working on constructing languages for these two cultures, through people who also lack the usually requisite nerd-shame. This is fantastic! For all that Klingons are a fierce warrior people, &c. &c., the Vulcan obsession with logic is far more interesting to me as a scholar. Romulans are even more interesting; somewhat mysterious, Paramount has not done much with the race beyond their use as vaguely treacherous and yet occasionally honourable bad guys who are nonetheless widely despised. Also, they are passionate Space pseudo-Romans. Learning that there are folk willing to expand out these tidbits into an artificial language or two warms the cold recesses of my heart.

It is an often overlooked fact in SF world-building that planets -continents! island chains!- are rarely monolingual. Europe is a pretty small area on the global scale and yet has dozens (hundreds?) of languages and dialects covering the continent in a patchwork. A throwaway line justifying multiple fan iterations of ‘Vulcan’ by pointing this out got me thinking. At present, the various Romulan and Vulcan projects appear to be disconnected, with no linguistic similarity between them at all. Furthermore, each is concentrating, rightly enough, on a single dialect of each language. I thought, ‘Wow, wouldn’t it be fun to design an entire family tree for these languages?’ After all, the Romulan and Vulcan peoples share a common ancestor- surely their languages must do the same. The saner parts of my brain tried to shout me down but alas! my insanity will not be denied.

If we look at a single language group within the Indo-European (IE) family, that of the Romance languages, we can see for ourselves how quickly languages may change. From the early years of the first millenium CE to the present day, Latin has evolved into French, Spanish, Italian, and Romanian. If one were to squint and look sideways, it is possible for one to see how the languages retain a common ancestor. Using the example phrase ‘She always closes the window before dining (or having dinner)’ from Wikipedia, we can see this:

Language Phrase
Latin [Illa] claudit semper fenestram antequam cenat.
French Elle ferme toujours la fenêtre avant de dîner/souper.
Spanish [Ella] siempre cierra la ventana antes de cenar.
Italian [Lei/Ella] chiude sempre la finestra prima di cenare.
Romanian Ea închide totdeauna fereastra înainte de cină.

Going further back, one may compare entire language groups. As an example, take Old English (a Germanic language) and place it alongside Old Irish (Celtic) and Latin (Italic) to clearly see that all three are closely related IE languages. Below are a handful of words which mostly serve to demonstrate the sound changes that have occured since Proto-Indo-European:

Latin Old Irish Old English Modern English
pater athair fæder father
tres trí þrīe three
dentis dēt tōđ tooth

Indo-European Family Tree; Wikipedia

Yet, particularly in the case of Old Irish, each is definitely distinct from the others. Special enough to satisfy the most energetic and enthusiastic creator of conlangs, and yet unified enough for the family tree idea I propose here.

In Vulcan ‘history’, around the 4thC CE on Terra occurred an event known as the Time of Awakening. The Vulcans as we see them on Star Trek -logical, dispassionate- were transformed into such by the teachings of Surak, a scientist-philosopher. The teachings are not entirely relevant to this discussion (not that they are detailed anyway), save to note their emphasis on pure logic in opposition to excessive emotion. Several factions resisted these teachings, and eventually left Vulcan. One such group would eventually settle on Romulus and become the Romulans. This split would also drive language diversity, but in the case of the Time of Awakening/Romulan diaspora there are politically motivated linguistic splits.

Let us call, for convenience, the language spoken by Surak at the Time of Awakening ‘Middle Vulcan’ (MV). It is from this language that modern Vulcan (MnV) dialects descended. We shall all the ancestor of this language ‘Old High Vulcan’ (OHV), which itself descended from older roots. This is vastly simplifying matters, of course, but I hope this is sufficient to demonstrate my point.

THE DISTANT PAST –> Old High Vulcan –> Middle Vulcan (c.400) — {reforms} –> Modern Vulcan (c.2300)

Modern Vulcan will have evolved from Middle Vulcan, but the language reforms introduced by Surak would have served to make the language more logical. Natural languages develop all sorts of weird and wonderful quirks, the most obvious of which are irregular verbs. ‘To be’ is notorious for this; so far as I am aware, ‘to be’ is irregular in all natural languages. Surak’s followers would reform their language to remove oddities such as this, as well as organising noun declensions or the like to work in a more regular pattern. Oddities similar to Latin’s domus would be streamlined. At this point, an organisation (similar to the Terran L’Académie française would be set up to monitor the language and ensure it remains logical- languages behave like living things and have a tendency to evolve in odd directions without guidance. All this would result in MnV behaving quite oddly as a language, being akin to a natural language evolved from OHV in places and yet like a conlang in others.

Naturally, there would be several dialects, possibly even languages, evolved from this. Vulcan was not completely unified during the Time of Awakening, and it is unlikely that a single language would be established as dominant very easily. Different groups interpreted Surak’s teachings in different ways and would evolve their languages from MV accordingly. Furthermore, with the eventual development of universal translators, why would one language become necessary? Logically it would be better to allow individual cultures to retain their autonomy and languages in order to further the diversity of Vulcan literature. Perhaps there is a dominant form, an international language or one used in diplomatic interactions with the Federation- or perhaps not. Star Trek is set in the 24thC CE, and two thousand years is more than sufficient time for languages to develop in a multitude of fascinating ways.

The people who became Romulans deliberately turned their backs on Surak’s logical reforms, preferring to remain an emotional and militaristic people. Diane Duane wrote several Star Trek novels centred on the Romulan people, and detailed how they developed their language. In order to differentiate themselves from their cousins on Vulcan, Romulan linguists artificially aged an older form of their language in a ‘different direction’. If we presume that what we have called OHV is the root language used, then ‘Middle Romulan’, the language developed by the reform, would differ considerably from Middle Vulcan, and yet be clearly related. MV would have a broadly similar patterns of noun declension and verb conjugation in order to be more easily learned, although artificial sound changes would lend the language an entirely different ‘feel’. The sound change from IE to proto-Germanic is a good example of how such changes could work. The problem would be constructing the language so that folk could easily adjust to it, and yet was distinct from MV.

Old High Vulcan — {artificial aging} –>Middle Romulan (c.500) –{evolution} –> Modern Romulan Dialects (c.2300)

The recent Star Trek movie (NuTrek) mentions in passing that there are three principal dialects of Romulan. I rather suspect these are languages rather than ‘dialects’ although I concede that the terms overlap to a certain extent. This is certainly reasonable, for a language family that has developed over almost two millenia (NuTrek is set in the 23rdC) almost certainly without the strictures of a language academy, but I think it would be fun to have only two of these languages be developed from MV. The other, which I shall call Low Romulan (LR) developed more directly from MV. This is the language of those who never quite adjusted to the language change of MR, although certainly words and concepts would have borrowed quite heavily from the rapidly-dominant Romulan tongue. I suspect LR would have been spoken by the lower classes, those for whom the flight from Vulcan was less a matter of choice and more of following their lords and leaders. All this gives Romulan languages quite a character and provides something for xenophilologists into which to sink their teeth.

I’m an historian, not a linguist; I can go no further with my idea than this. This proposal would require a great deal of work, requiring as it does the development of one conlang (Old High Vulcan) and then the artificial-but-seemingly-natural development for Middle Vulcan and later Modern Vulcan; the artificial Middle Romulan and then the natural development of Modern Romulan (1, 2) as well as Low Romulan. A great deal of work, particularly in dictionaries. My own study of languages enables me to pick up the basics of grammar relatively easily; it is in vocabulary that I always stumble, easily bored by repetitive chanting. Nonetheless, a project such as this would be extremely rewarding, particularly for those who -like myself- are fascinated by historical linguistics.

Who is with me?